A structurally advantaged W2 telehealth practice running a paid acquisition engine that is leaking 50% of its qualified demand at a single mechanical step. The patient is real, the providers are real, the demand is real — the constraint is the verification stage between form-fill and first appointment, and every other lever multiplies through it.
| Channel | Spend % | Stated CPA | Contribution | Trend | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Google Search | 86% | $246 | ~50 patients/mo | ↑ CPC +42% YoY (category) | Over-Invested |
| Performance Max | 6% | $55 | ~50 conversions/mo | ↓ CPA stable | Under-Invested |
| Meta Ads | 2% | N/A — Pixel broken | 0 measurable | $0.38 CPC, 1.87% CTR | Misallocated |
| PCP Referral Network | — | $50–100 est. | 2 informal partners | Dormant 5 yrs | Latent |
| AEO / Organic | — | $0 marginal | ~0 patients | Cat. shift: −58% CTR to AI | Latent |
| Metric We Need | Current State | Unblock | Owner | Window |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Booked Appt → New Patient rate (overall) | Data Gap IntakeQ/EHR linkage blocked | BAA execution + IntakeQ data flow into BQ | Anthony + Mary Kay + legal | D0–D30 · gating |
| Booked Appt → New Patient by channel | Data Gap no UTM persistence | UTM stitched into IntakeQ patient record at form-fill | Eng + Senior Growth Marketer | D14–D45 |
| Cost of Booked Appt by channel | Partial Stated CPA = form-fill, not booked appt (Search $246 · PMax $55) | Redefine Google Ads + Meta conversion event from "form-fill" to "booked appt" (offline upload from IntakeQ post-BAA) | Senior Growth Marketer | D7–D21 |
| Cost of New Patient by channel | Data Gap blended only (~$800 effective) | UTM persistence + redefined conversion + SIG-12 monthly P&L | Jarred + Doug | D30–D60 |
| GA4 default-channel-group breakout | Broken property G-TX7C26MFBE deprecated | Audit existing GA4 or replace; configure form-fill + booked-appt events | Josh Flores + Anthony | D14 deliverable |
| SEO KPIs vs benchmark (avg position · CTR · impressions) | Data Gap GSC access blocked on OAuth 2FA · 5-year baseline ≈ 0 organic patients | Google OAuth 2FA confirm; SIG-07 weekly GSC delta signal live | Anthony (2FA) + Senior Growth Marketer | D1–D3 |
| Sources by booking CVR (GA4) | Data Gap sequenced behind GA4 + booking-event def | GA4 fix → booking-event configured → 30-day baseline accumulates | Senior Growth Marketer + Mary Kay | D14–D60 |
| Brand | Positioning | Creative / Messaging | Channel Strength | Where they win | Where we win |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MindRx Group |
W2 telepsych specialty practice; insurance-billed; OR/WA only | Generic mental-health framing. W2 / in-state moat under-claimed; stale "Morgan" testimonials; Winter Hawks invisible | Google Search (concentrated) | — | — |
LifeStance Health |
"Outcomes-focused practice management" — 8K clinicians, FY25 profitable ($1.42B rev, $146M cash flow) | Outcomes-led; payer-network breadth as headline; aspirational clinician imagery | Paid Search · SEO · Brand | Scale, payer breadth, M&A capacity (PNW consolidation risk for clinician labor) | In-state continuity; PMHNP specialization; founder-led culture |
Talkiatry |
"Value-based behavioral health" + AI scribe; 800+ psychiatrists, 60+ payers, 45 states | MD-credentialed authority lead; AI scribe as differentiator; tech-forward UX | Paid Social · Brand · SEO | Series D Feb 2026 ($210M); MD-heavy roster appeals to acuity-conscious patients | PMHNP workforce-growth lane; in-state regulatory simplicity; insurance-billed continuity |
Cerebral |
Subscription telehealth; controlled-substance prescribing footprint shrinking post-DOJ/FTC settlements | Discount/access-led; brand recovery-mode after $3.6M DOJ + $7M FTC settlements | Paid Social · Brand recovery | Brand recall (negative-leaning); price accessibility | Trust position (W2, never DEA-vulnerable); insurance-billed continuity; OR/WA depth |
Done Global |
ADHD-focused 1099 telemedicine — founder convicted Nov 18, 2025 (federal drug distribution) | Effectively dormant for new-patient acquisition post-conviction | — | Pre-2025: ADHD search-term dominance, now collapsing | Direct beneficiary of patient migration away from convicted operator |
Headway |
Insurance-first marketplace for therapists/coaches; Series D Jul 2024 at $2.3B valuation | Marketplace-discovery framing; "find a therapist" hook; payer-acceptance breadth | SEO · Paid Search · Brand | SEO scale on therapist-search terms; payer-network breadth | Psychiatric medication management (not therapy-only); W2 continuity vs. marketplace churn |
Brightside |
Subscription-priced med + therapy; Series C-II Jul 2025 (back-to-back C rounds) | Subscription-pricing transparency hook; member-care framing | Paid Social · Brand | Subscription pricing simplicity for the cash-pay segment | Insurance-billed (no surprise fees); W2 clinician continuity |
Two Chairs Psychiatry |
"In-home + telehealth psychiatric care" — W2, insurance-billed; not in OR/WA per current footprint | Hybrid in-home + telehealth as differentiator; clinician-quality narrative | Brand · Paid Search | Hybrid in-home model where deployed | OR/WA market presence and payer-panel depth |
Mindful Therapy Group |
Portland-local; therapy-leaning; mixed model (1099 weighted) | Local-clinician network framing; therapist-led acquisition | Local SEO · Brand | Local SEO on Portland-specific terms; therapist density | W2 retention model; insurance-billed continuity; PMHNP medication-management depth |
| Brand | Primary Acquisition Lever | Content / mo | PCP Referral Structure | Webinar / CME | AEO / SEO Authority | Outbound |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MindRx Group |
Google Search (concentrated) | ~0 | 2 informal | None | ~0 organic patients · 5 yrs | None |
LifeStance |
SEO + Paid Search + Brand | 12+ | Structured PCP outreach in major metros | Quarterly clinical-content webinars | Top-3 on "find a psychiatrist [city]" | Payer-side relationships |
Talkiatry |
Paid Search + AEO + Brand | 10+ | Tech-stack referral integrations (Epic) | CME credits for PCPs | AI-Overview cited on insurance Qs | Employer-side B2B2C |
Headway |
SEO marketplace | 20+ (therapist profiles) | Marketplace discovery (no formal PCP) | None | Dominant on "therapist [insurance]" | Therapist-side recruiting |
Two Chairs |
Brand + Paid Search | ~6 | Hybrid PCP + in-home referral | Targeted clinician CME | Mid-tier on category Qs | Healthcare-system partnerships |
Brightside |
Paid Social + Brand | ~4 | None formal | None | Mid-tier on "depression treatment" | None |
Cerebral |
Paid Social (recovery-mode) | ~3 | None | None | Brand-recovery focused | None |
Mindful Therapy Group |
Local SEO + Brand | ~2 | Local-PCP informal | None | Local Portland authority | None |
| Metric | Healthy | Trigger | Action | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Verification Pass Rate | > 65% (D60), 75% (D90) | < 55% / 7 days | Mary Kay billing audit; landing-page payer pre-screen check; reroute Tier 3 traffic to manual queue within 48 hrs | Mary Kay |
| Effective Patient CPA | < $600 | > $750 / 14 days | Pause bottom-quartile keywords; reallocate 10% Search → PMax; verify SIG-02 not regressing | Jarred (MH-1 GM) |
| 1★ Trailing-90d Share | < 10% | > 15% / 30 days | SIG-11 keyword-mining surfaces topic; escalate to billing/admin track; pause Loop 4 prompting until clean | Mary Kay + Jarred |
| Form-Fill Rate | ≥ 200 / mo (paid + organic) | < 150 / mo / 14 days | Audit GA4 + Meta tracking; check landing-page conversion math; ship A/B test on hero asset within 72 hrs | Senior Growth Marketer |
| AEO Citations on Target Queries | ≥ 3 cited (D90) | 0 cited / 60 days | SIG-08 weekly audit reviewed; content-format adjustment (FAQ schema, payer-specific Q&A); ship 1 article/wk | Senior Growth Marketer |
| Active PCP Partnerships | ≥ 5 active (D90) | < 3 active / 60 days | Outreach cadence audit; case-presentation calendar reset; clinician-to-clinician CME proposals shipped within 2 weeks | Jarred + Cary |